Putting one's money in emerging regional
countries has paid off well for a Singapore investor in the last 11
years
THE headline news for this paper yesterday was 'MAS springs
another Sing dollar surprise'.
'The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) surprised markets
yesterday by signalling that it will allow faster gains in the
Singapore dollar to fight inflation, sending the currency to an
all-time high against the US dollar,' it was reported.
Fluctuations in foreign exchange have always been a factor to
consider in any offshore investments, and perhaps particularly so
now given the increasing talk of a currency war erupting.
I was reminded of a comment made by a chief financial officer of
a Singapore group with numerous investments overseas. 'It's tough
for Singapore companies to invest overseas because of the
appreciating Singapore dollar. Most of the gains one makes will be
gone once converted back to Singapore dollars.'
Of course, this friend exaggerates. Yes, the Singapore dollar has
been on this inexorable march upwards against most currencies in the
region. But the appreciation has not been so great as to wipe out
all the investment returns.
Of the 12 countries I looked at, the currency of only one country
managed to gain against the Singapore dollar, and that country is
Australia. The Aussie dollar strengthened by about 18 per cent
against the Sing dollar in the past decade.
All the other countries' currencies weakened vis-a-vis the Sing
dollar. The Indonesian rupiah has lost the most against the Sing
dollar. Between the beginning of 2000 and now, the rupiah has
declined by about 38 per cent against the city-state's currency. The
US dollar, British pound, Hong Kong dollar, Korean won, India's
rupee, the Philippines' peso and the New Taiwan dollar fell by
between 20 and 28 per cent.
The Indonesian market
The Thai baht, Chinese yuan and Malaysian ringgit held up pretty
well against the Sing dollar. Each declined between 2.4 per cent and
3.6 per cent.
So obviously, for those who have invested in the Indonesian
market, the investment return has to be more than 38 per cent
between 2000 and now for an investor to be making a positive return
in Singapore dollar terms. The hurdle rates for the other markets
are lower.
So have investments into these offshore bourses paid off for
investors?
In most cases, yes, and some pretty big time at that. For
example, the Jakarta Composite Index advanced by 415 per cent
between Jan 7, 2000 and Oct 8, 2010. In those years, the companies
also distributed dividends. Assuming the dividends were reinvested
back into the index, the return in those 11 years or so is a
whopping 710 per cent. That's a 20-odd per cent compounded return a
year.
But as mentioned earlier, the rupiah declined by about 38 per
cent against the Singapore dollar during that period. Converting the
return back to Singapore dollar, what's an investor's net return?
Well, it's 414.5 per cent. That's still a very good return of 16 per
cent compounded every year over the last 11 years or so.
The second best-performing bourse is Bombay's Sensex which
returned 250 per cent between 2000 and 2010 in Sing dollar terms.
The Stock Exchange of Thailand is not too far behind with a return
of 213 per cent.
Worst-performing indices
As for investors in the Australian market, they'd be in the happy
situation of having seen their investment return boosted further by
the appreciation of the Aussie dollar against the Sing dollar. That
bolstered total return by more than 40 percentage points in the last
decade.
Meanwhile, the S&P 500 in the United States and London's FTSE 100
are the two worst-performing indices we looked at. They were down by
19.2 per cent and 13 per cent respectively. But their depreciating
currencies compounded the loss to a Singapore-based investor.
Fortunately for investors in the FTSE 100, the stocks there
distributed quite a bit of dividends over the years. And that made
up for almost all the losses - both in price and currency
depreciation.
The S&P 500 wasn't as generous in its dividend distributions,
according to data from Bloomberg. Consequently, a Singapore-based
investor would be down by about 22.7 per cent in all.
The Taiwan Stock Exchange is the second worse-performing market
of the 12 overseas markets we looked at. The decline in its currency
is the major culprit for its poor performance to a Singapore
investor. However, dividends made up for a large part of those
losses, and a Singapore investor would be down by a marginal 1.6 per
cent.
But the real loss of course is the opportunity cost. Had the
investor just put his or her money in the Singapore market, they
would have reaped a return of 37 per cent in capital appreciation.
For some reason, Bloomberg didn't have the dividend figures for the
Straits Times Index. Including dividend, I reckoned the total return
in the Singapore market would amount to some 70 per cent. That's
none too spectacular, at just about 5 per cent a year.
But as can be seen from the table, dividends - reinvested into
the market - actually form a big part of the total return for most
of the markets we look at. So don't sniff at the dividends you get.
The market that saw the smallest contribution from dividends is
the Shanghai Composite Index.
All in all, putting one's money in emerging regional countries
has paid off well for a Singapore investor in the last 11 years.
Perhaps one reason could be that because of their weak currencies,
companies in those markets are competitive globally and hence that
shows up in their bottom line.
Extra bonus
The good news now is that according to data compiled by StarMine,
despite the very strong run-up in the prices of many regional
bourses, valuations still don't look stretched. Markets such as
Korea, Vietnam, Australia, Taiwan and Thailand are still trading at
less than 13 times analysts' forecast earnings for the next 12
months.
Singapore, on the other hand, is trading at 13.9 times forward
earnings. So from that perspective, there appears to still be value
in investing in regional bourses. And going forward in the next 10
years, it may even be possible for us to see some of these regional
currencies appreciating vis-a-vis the Sing dollar as their economies
develop. That will be the additional bonus all investors investing
overseas are looking forward to.
The writer is a CFA charterholder